By Canadian Press

Canada lags behind allies as NATO plans to increase defence spending targets

Jul 11, 2023 | 1:04 AM

VILNIUS, Lithuania — NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg has made no secret of the fact that he wants more from member nations at this year’s leaders’ summit. 

Exactly how much more is still a matter for discussion, but the 31 states with NATO membership are expected to make a more ambitious pledge than they have to date. 

The agreed-upon target has been for each country to spend about two per cent of its GDP on defence. 

Now, that is expected to just be the minimum.

Canada has agreed to the target but has not revealed a plan to reach it, with current spending sitting just shy of 1.3 per cent and political leaders including Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Defence Minister Anita Anand shrugging off suggestions Canadians are not pulling their weight.

1000 Ways to Heal

1000 Ways to Heal: Moons

Dec 10, 2024

Question of the Week

Should Mayor Reid Hamer-Jackson apologize or resign after it was found he breached a section of council's code of conduct for allowing false or misleading information to be communicated?

Dec 09, 2024

One Man's Opinion

COLLINS: Donald has it wrong - again

Dec 08, 2024

But some observers say the time has come for Canada to signal to allies that it is serious about meeting its goals.

“I don’t think that Canada can just keep its head down and avoid this,” said Tim Sayle, a NATO historian and professor at the University of Toronto. 

Sayle said allies will likely step up their pressure on countries like Canada, Germany, Denmark and Belgium, which are lagging behind. 

Long-standing domestic issues are also playing a role in Canada’s global reputation, Carleton University professor Stephen Saideman said. 

“They have not fixed the procurement processes,” he said.

“They have a personnel shortage. Together, those two things make it hard, just simply hard, to spend money. Even if you allocate a lot of money, the actual spending of it is hard.”

The changes expected at this year’s summit include new European defence plans and a defence production action plan, which Stoltenberg said earlier this week will “aggregate demand, boost capacity, and increase interoperability.”

Defence procurement processes in Canada are notoriously long and often fraught with controversy as domestic and foreign players compete for lucrative contracts. 

“In some ways, there could be attractive solutions to Canada working with other allies in the development and procurement space. The problem we run into is that procurement is such an important part of domestic politics,” Sayle said.

Right now, Canadian company Bombardier is teaming up with General Dynamics in a bid to encourage the federal government to award them a contract to replace the aging Aurora surveillance aircraft fleet. 

The government has insisted it is pursuing a competitive process, but it has taken steps to get approval from the United States State Department to purchase as many as 16 advanced P-8A Poseidon planes. 

In a briefing before the NATO summit, senior government officials noted that the federal government has increased defence spending by 70 per cent since 2014. The officials provided a briefing to journalists under the condition of anonymity. 

“It is certainly true this government has spent more money in the military. It’s certainly true it has tried to spend more money in the military,” Saideman said. 

On Monday, Trudeau announced plans to spend $2.6 billion over three years to boost the Canadian presence on NATO’s eastern flank by growing a Canada-led multinational battle group in Latvia to a brigade by 2026. 

His government has also pledged around $40 billion on Norad modernization, along with billions on purchasing F-35 fighter jets and building new naval ships. All of that will increase the amount the country spends. 

Earlier this year, a Washington Post report cited leaked documents that said that Trudeau had privately told U.S. officials Canada would not meet the spending target. 

“Part of that was a matter of being honest about our limitations, and part of it was this government’s priorities,” Saideman said.

“It doesn’t want to spend two per cent on the military, because that would mean either raising taxes or spending less money on something else.”

In a statement on Monday, Conservative party defence critic James Bezan and foreign-affairs critic Michael Chong argued that Canada’s role as a “trusted and reliable” partner has diminished. 

“Our troops are struggling to do the jobs their country is asking of them due to personnel shortages and a lack of equipment,” the statement said. 

“Prime Minister Trudeau has a chance at the Vilnius Summit to make a commitment to address this neglect.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 11, 2023.

— With files from Dylan Robertson.

Sarah Ritchie, The Canadian Press