By Canadian Press

Miller ‘dumfounded’ appeal dropped over Catholic Church’s residential school payments

Nov 6, 2021 | 9:40 AM

OTTAWA — Newly named Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Marc Miller says he wants to get to the bottom of why Ottawa abandoned its appeal of a ruling releasing the Catholic Church from its settlement obligations to residential school survivors. 

“I am as puzzled as everyone,” he told The Canadian Press in a recent, wide-ranging interview.” 

“I don’t know what there is to do yet.” 

The ruling, handed down by a Saskatchewan judge in July 2015, found a deal had been struck between the federal government and a corporation of Catholic entities. That deal released the church groups from their remaining obligations within the $79-million worth of payments and in-kind services owed to survivors under the Indian Residential School Settlement Agreement, approved in 2006. 

That included, for example, a “best efforts” fundraising campaign to generate $25 million, for which court only heard the groups raised around $3 million since the agreement took effect in 2007.

Question of the Week

Do you start decorating for Christmas before December 1?

8h ago

One Man's Opinion

COLLINS: John Rustad's big gamble

Nov 24, 2024

Two and Out

PETERS: Eby could learn something from Horgan, who bridged the ideological divide between urban and rural B.C.

Nov 22, 2024

Today, the efforts made by Catholic bodies to relieve itself of responsibilities under the historic arrangement face renewed scrutiny as First Nations searching former residential school sites confirm the discovery of what are believed to be hundreds of unmarked graves of Indigenous children forced to attend them. 

Thousands told the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada that they had been neglected, starved, and both physically and sexually abused at the church-run, government-funded institutions.

Several questions have been raised around why survivors didn’t receive more compensation from the Catholic Church, including why the federal government discontinued its appeal filed not long after the 2015 decision came down.

“I question why that refusal to appeal occurred,” Miller said. 

“As everyone, I’m dumbfounded by it. End of the day the whole point was about compensation.”

At the heart of the legal ruling was a dispute between a government lawyer and counsel for the Catholic entities about whether they had agreed to let the groups walk away from all obligations outlined in the settlement in exchange for $1.2 million, or only resolved a more specific part of those obligations. 

The disagreement occurred as they went back-and-forth communicating details of the arrangement. It ultimately fell to the court to resolve the issue, with Catholic entities contending they had a deal covering the entire settlement and Ottawa asserting that wasn’t true. 

After the federal government lost its case, it filed a notice to appeal in August 2015. Overshadowing the matter at the time was a federal election campaign consuming the country, which ended that October with the former Conservative government falling to current Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. 

By November, a government lawyer submitted another document to Saskatchewan’s Appeal Court. This time, it contained a single sentence saying it was abandoning the appeal.

Miller, who was then a rookie MP from Quebec not yet invited into cabinet, said he hasn’t seen the final agreement releasing the Catholic bodies from their obligations, but wants to have a look. 

“I absolutely do want to see it. I want to get to the bottom of it,” he said.

Miller enters the Crowns-Indigenous Relations office after critics and First Nations leaders called for former minister Carolyn Bennett to be dumped. 

She was criticized both for a text she sent to Indigenous, then Independent MP Jody Wilson-Raybould which the former justice minister labelled as racist, as well as not doing enough to advance the department’s mandate of building a new nation-to-nation relationship with Indigenous communities.

Hours after being sworn into his new role, Miller said last week that land was at the centre of that relationship, and it was time to “give land back.”

“It’s sort of unfair to have piecemeal examples of which particular parcel could be returned,” he said, outlining how his department must work alongside other federal ministries, like defence, to find ways for lands to be bought back. 

“It needs to sit squarely in people’s minds that the relationship that has become broken with Indigenous Peoples did start with land, and it will be solved by returning land.”

The Liberals’ commitment to reconciliation has been tested over the past six months, not only by the discovery of unmarked graves, but also its ongoing court battle around compensating First Nations children who lived on-reserve without adequately funded child and family services or were separated from their families through foster care.

More tension arose after Trudeau traveled to Tofino, B.C., to spend time with his family on Sept. 30, the country’s first National Day for Truth and Reconciliation. The stated purpose of the new statutory holiday is to honour residential school survivors through taking time to reflect and attending in-person commemorations. 

Trudeau has said travelling that day was a mistake, and has since visited B.C.’s Tkemlups te Secwépemc nation after not responding to their initial invitation to do so on Sept. 30. 

Asked what the Prime Minister’s trip did to the government’s process of trying to build trust with First Nations, Miller said it “doesn’t help.” 

“I think the Prime Minister would be the first to recognize that.” 

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 6, 2021

Stephanie Taylor, The Canadian Press